Rick's On Main in New York

"We celebrated 30th anniversary and wanted it to be special. Wife has been here before, my 1st time. Her sea bass, light flaky, perfect cook. Her risotto, delicious. I had the wagyu medium rare. The seasoning was delicious, the sear was a perfect, I mean perfect char. Perfect grill pattern. The green beans were a perfect cook where they still have that snap of freshness. Our waiter, perfect knowledgeable and friendly. Recommend to anyone wishing to find a place with a nice atmosphere for a special occasion. Price is high, but congruent with level of quality."

"We had a great time, the atmosphere is excellent. Bartender was very talented, and very fast. Our waiter was very nice and kind, but didn't blow us away. My wife's seafood risotto was excellent, would say it was a five-star dish. My steak was four star, not the best I've ever had but definitely over average. The crab cakes were the best I've ever had in my life! Would definitely return, very excited for our next outing to come to Rick's on Main!"

"The most tender and flavorful steak I have ever ate! The meal was fabulous no words canbdescribe how good this meal really was. Go try it, you will not be sorry. The mashed potatoes, asparagus and caramelized onions matched perfectly with the steak. The boom boom shrimp and stuffed banana peppers were ridiculous. The staff was extremely knowledgeable, helpful and attentive. I wish I would have had room for dessert, as I'm sure it would have been great!"

"My boyfriend and I have been here twice, and it has been incredible both times! Last night we were there to celebrate our anniversary, and had such an amazing time! I strongly recommend this restaurant!!"

"My shower was absolutely perfect. The food was great and the space was perfect. We had 20-25 girls. The staff was super helpful and accommodating. 10/10 top to bottom. My only complaint is how dark it is upstairs. All of the lighting looked dark and off in pictures so I wish they had better lighting for day time events, instead of just night time dinner lighting. We made the most of it!"

"Was in for the first today 3/27/25. Everything was delicious! Can’t wait to go back. Service was great. It was a bit dark upstairs but not crazy. Cannoli cake was fantastic. If I need a cake I would order one from there I thought it was that good."

"This was my first visit to Rick's on Main and it did not disappoint. This little place is a perfect spot for all occasions. This is an upper class casual place that will hit your pocket book but is well worth the price. My gf and I started off with soup. She had the loaded potato soup and I went with the lobster bisque. Both were excellent. For dinner we both went with steak. I had the wagyu strip and she had the filet. Both steaks were cooked to perfection and were delicious. We ended up saving room for dessert and both of those were a delightful finish to our meals. Our server was very polite, attentive and knowledgeable. The restaurant itself is laid out neatly with different rooms allowing for similar but different experiences. I do not drink but they have a nice bar area with plenty of options. I definitely look forward to going back to this establishment at some point. If you're in the East Aurora area it's definitely somewhere you should try for a spectacular dinner. This place is a 5 out of 5 stars."

"This restaurant is very cozy and intimate. Great for a special occasion. We didn’t have a reservation but were able to be seated immediately. People tend to dress nicely when coming here, i was meeting a friend after work so i wasn’t able to dress up but they didn’t seem to mind. However some of the locals in the dining room gave us some looks, i guess that’s just East Aurora for you. This place is very expensive and i must say i thought the food was quite average. The calamari is served in a pool of tomato sauce and it ended up being soggy rather than crispy. My friend ordered the cowboy steak which was cooked perfectly. The potato croquettes seemed to lack flavor. My seafood risotto also seemed to lack flavor, it was good, but not $52.95 good. We spent $200 here and i left unimpressed. I wouldn’t say that i don’t recommend this place, because it wasn’t bad, but for a $200 experience i think there might be some better places to go."